Socrates kind of said, “I will go where my argument leads me.” (The phrase “I will go where my argument leads me” is a common paraphrase of a famous philosophical principle attributed to Socrates in Plato’s dialogues—most notably in The Republic (394d), where he states: “Wherever the argument, like a wind, tends, there we must go.”)
What happens when one goes where one’s reason or emotion leads one?
David Hume (1711–1776), a prominent Scottish Enlightenment philosopher, historian, economist, and essayist. He is best known for his radical empiricism, philosophical skepticism, and naturalistic approach to human nature, went where his reason led him and he ended up with this truth:
“’Tis not unreasonable for me to prefer the destruction of the whole world to the scratching of my finger.” — David Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature (Book 2, Part 3, Section 3)
What happens when one goes where one’s emotion leads one?
The answer is not hard to find. Just leaf through the annals of human history.
How come we land in such bleak territory when one follows reason or emotion to its logical conclusion?
The reason for that is that reason and emotion are merely tools at one’s disposal for using to navigate through life. When they are used more and more in service of one’s own personal self or anything else connected with it, such as one’s own family, one’s own lineage, one’s own group, one’s own country, one’s own race, one’s own profession, one’s own religion, etc., the at the extreme one lands up in the above two scenarios.
What then is the solution?
One has to cultivate correct understanding of the nature of this world, the nature of the reality underlying this world (the logos or Ṛta) so that one moves closer and closer to one’s universal empathic self that is predisposed towards this world and all its constituents in the mode of compassion. Then comes about the correct use of reason and emotion.
Let us look at this observation through the lens of Nietzsche.
Nietzsche said in his 1883 philosophical novel Thus Spoke Zarathustra: “man is a rope stretched between the animal and the Superman [Between Beast and Overman (Übermensch)].”
Reason and emotion are used in different ways depending on which end of the rope one is at.
But, of course, the Übermensch for our purposes here is not the “blond beast” (die blonde Bestie), as Nietzsche’s sister and the Nazis tried to distort Nietzsche’s concept, nor even Nietzsche’s original concept of the superman.
Google AI explains:
The “blonde beast” and the Übermensch (Overman) are two distinct yet frequently conflated concepts introduced by German philosopher Nietzsche.
The “Blonde Beast” (die blonde Bestie)
- Definition: Appeared primarily in Nietzsche’s On the Genealogy of Morality, the “blonde beast” is a metaphor for a primal, predatory, and noble creature—analogous to a lion—rather than a literal racial designation.
- Characteristics: It represents uninhibited vitality, strength, joy in conquering, and an absence of internal moral guilt, traits Nietzsche associated with ancient warrior aristocracies (such as Roman, Greek, Arabic, and early Germanic elites).
- The Lion Metaphor: In Nietzsche’s framework of cultural evolution, the “beast” signifies raw, instinctive power before it was suppressed or poisoned by what he termed “slave morality” (Judeo-Christian values).
The Übermensch (Overman)
- Definition: Introduced in Thus Spoke Zarathustra, the Übermensch is Nietzsche’s ideal future human who overcomes nihilism, rejects traditional religious or herd morality, and creates their own life-affirming values.
- The Three Metamorphoses: To reach this state, humanity must pass through three symbolic stages:
- The Camel: The bearer of heavy burdens who internalizes traditional duties and moral rules.
- The Lion: The rebel who utters a “sacred no,” tearing down old values and authority (this is where the aggressive, destructive energy of the “beast” overlaps slightly).
- The Child: The playful, innocent creator who says a “sacred yes” to life and originates brand-new, life-affirming values.
The Connection and Misconception
- Not the same thing: The “blonde beast” is a backward-looking or historical/primal type (the ancient warlord or untamed hunter), whereas the Übermensch is forward-looking—a psychological and cultural evolution who has mastered and sublimated their raw drives rather than just acting as a savage predator.
- Nazi Appropriation: 20th-century National Socialist ideology dangerously distorted and fused both terms, literalizing the “blonde beast” into a fantasy of an “Aryan” master race and misinterpreting the Übermensch as a biological conqueror rather than an individual of self-overcoming. In reality, Nietzsche despised German nationalism and antisemitism.
So, instead, for the purposes of our write-up here, I would like to characterize Übermensch as one who is a Sthitaprajna, as adumbrated in the Bhagavad Gita. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sthitaprajna)