Here’s an article “Reflections on Predetermination and Free Will“, which I wrote something like 20 years before, one which was published in Sri Ramana Jyothi, a bilingual monthlyu publication of Sri Ramana Kendra, Hyderabad:
“Yes, everything is predetermined. … As for freedom for man, he is always free not to identify himself with the body and not to be affected by the pleasures or pains consequent on the body’s activities.”—Sri Ramana Maharshi (Day by day with Bhagavan, 4-1-46 Afternoon)
There is a dilemma in accepting what Bhagavan is saying in the above quote, that is, everything is predetermined but we have freedom to identify or not with the body. That leads to a contradiction and paradox, because when we exercise the freedom to identify or not with the body that changes the texture of our thoughts and desires, which in turn affects the bodily actions, and so bodily actions cannot be predetermined, or at least not all of them. For common-sensical and logical consistency, one of the two propositions has to be wrong – that is, either everything is not predetermined or we do not have the freedom to identify or not with the body (i.e., that also is predetermined). I can present one scenario (which can be extrapolated in many different directions and dimensions) which would persuade one that everything is predetermined, including, the spiritual sadhana you would put in this life and when and how you will become enlightened. Later I will try and present an argument as to why that need not deter us from putting in the effort or more correctly that will not deter us in doing what we “want” to do.
Venkataraman Iyer (future Ramana Maharshi) was born in 1879. He attained self-realization in 1896 at the age of 17. Now, let us say someone was born in 1884, that is, when Venkataraman was 5 years old. Let us say this person, upon hearing about Ramana Maharshi in 1925, decides to pay a visit to him in Tiruvannamalai. This person’s bodily actions are predetermined as per Ramana’s contention at the time of his birth. Which would mean, his going to meet Ramana Maharshi in 1925 was already predetermined in 1884 at the time of his birth, when Venkataraman was only 5 years old. So, when Venkataraman was only 5 years old it was already predetermined that he would be Ramana Maharshi, the realized sage, in 1925, which would entail that he must have realized his Self before that, otherwise this person would not go and meet him. So, Venkataraman’s self-realization, was also predetermined. That would also be entailed even if seen from Venkataraman’s body perspective. If he was predetermined to leave his house at the age of 17 and go and settle in Tiruvannamalai at the foothills of Arunachala, he would have done that only if he had realized his Self, so his Self-realization was already predetermined at the time of his birth. Which shows that he did not really have the “freedom” to identify or not with his body, but was carried along a divine current into self-realization.
Now, two questions arise: (1) Why did Bhagavan say we have freedom to identify with the body or not, when we clearly know through reasoning that we do not, and (2) Where does such a reasoning leave us with regard to effort and striving in our lives.
(1) Bhagavan did not have the freedom to say otherwise; that is, it was God himself speaking through Ramana those words, which are less of a lie and more of a truism and noble lie because by saying so, we are motivated to put in the effort, through God’s guile or leela, if you will. That is how God accomplishes his plan through us, by creating the illusion that we are in control and not by putting a gun to our heads and forcing us to do what he wants. God acts in the world where we are made to see illusory causes and effects for actions that he himself does through us. So, it is just a game that God is playing. That is why the world is said to be God’s leela.
(2) Where does that leave us with regard to effort. Strictly speaking, if one takes on board that everything is predetermined, then one surrenders completely and utterly to God at once (of course, you could ask at this point do we have that freedom – yes, in the sense that the very understanding that everything is predetermined occasions or causes the surrender) and that is the end of story – you will be liberated and ego, the locus of free will and fate, will be at an end. If not, if one does not believe it fully, then through the illusion that we are in control we will put in effort as per God’s plan and we will carry on. If one is caught in between, that is, one is fatalistic about life without surrendering fully, life (or God, if you will) will correct that attitude in us through other series of causal mechanisms and understandings.
So, yes, everything is predetermined, including the spiritual sadhana and effort that one puts forth in one’s life and so it is already predetermined when one will realize the Self, though the knowledge of “what is predetermined” in our lives is hidden from us, but sometimes we get glimpses of it through a good palmist or astrologer.