Does This Man Have a Right to the Data From His Own Brain? — An NYT Article


By Vivian Wang

J. Galen Buckwalter cheerfully agreed to provide his neural data for a research study. But when he asked for a copy, things got complicated.

Already, brain-computer interfaces have enabled people with paralysis to fly drones and helped people who have lost the ability to speak to communicate — using just their thoughts. Eventually, researchers say, they could allow the regulation of emotions such as pain or fear; the instant transfer of knowledge, such as a new language; or the merging of human consciousness with artificial intelligence.

Buckwalter, 70, was almost totally paralyzed from the chest down after a diving accident in his teens. He signed up for the study, conducted jointly by Caltech and the University of Southern California, because he wanted to make life better for others like him.

But when he asked the researchers for access to the data — after the craniotomy, after weeks of recovery, after hours upon hours in the lab — they said no.

The output from his brain belonged to the researchers, they said, not to him.

Today, the argument over who controls some of the most intimate information about us — what we buy, where we travel, whom we text — has become familiar, even tired. But little has been said about brain data. That is largely because that data has seemed like the stuff of science fiction, accessible only to scientists armed with the most specialized technology.

But that is quickly changing. Researchers and private companies are exploring other applications of brain-computer interfaces, including wearable headsets and caps. Elon Musk has a company, Neuralink, that has already implanted more than a dozen people, and he has said he envisions a world where people can upgrade themselves by merging with computers. Someday, information about how we think, what we fear and the essence of who we are could be as accessible as our shopping history on Amazon.

Yet, at least for now, there are few rules in place for who controls it.

Read the full article here:

Leave a Reply