Authority, Fear, Violence, Ideals, Morality, Relationships, Choiceless Awareness — J. Krishnamurti


The Friend’s Query: “So the big question is do we at all understand where we are headed ❓”

“It’s not going to some place, sir, but understanding this fact that most of us live a life in this ambience, in this cage of authority, fear and violence. We can’t go beyond it, unless one is free from it, not intellectually or theoretically, but actually be free from every form of authority, not the authority of the expert, but the feeling of dependence on authority.”–J. Krishnamurti

Huston Smith:

Are we trying to see then these things that stand between us and lucidity and freedom, we find authority and fear and violence working together to obstruct us, where do we go from there?

Krishnamurti:

I don’t see why it [total lucidity and freedom] shouldn’t be found by anybody who is really quite serious. Most of us are not serious at all, we want to be entertained, we want to be told what to do, we want someone else to tell us how to live, what this clarity is, what is truth, what is god, what is righteous behaviour and so on. Now if we could discard completely all the authority of psychological specialists, as well as the specialists in religion, if one could really deeply negate all authority of that kind, then one would be relying totally on oneself.

What is necessary is the freedom from authority, not the ‘how’. The ‘how’ implies a method, a system, a way trodden by others, and someone to tell you, do this and you will find it.

And the moment you have a system and a method you become mechanical, you just do what you are told. And that’s not clarity. It is like a child being told by its mother what it should be from morning until night. And therefore it becomes dependent on the mother, or the father, whatever it be, and there is no clarity. So to have clarity, the first essential thing is freedom. Freedom from authority.

I should think that’s a wrong question, the ‘how’. But rather if you say, what are the things, the obstructions that prevent clarity, then we can go into it. But if you say right from the beginning, what is the method – there have been a dozen methods and they have all failed, they have not produced clarity, or enlightenment, or a state of peace in man. On the contrary these methods have divided man; you have your method, and somebody else has his method, and these methods are everlastingly quarrelling with each other.

I think that is the only way. The positive way of the ‘how’ has lead man to divide himself, his loyalties, his pursuits, you have the ‘how’ of yours, and the ‘how’ of somebody else, and the method of this and they are all lost.

So what is important is to find out what are the obstructions, the hindrances, the blocks that prevent clear perception of human anxiety, fear, sorrow, and the ache of loneliness, the utter lack of love and all that.

Authority is destructive. So there are two problems involved in this question of authority: there is not only the authority of the expert – let’s call him for the moment – which is necessary, but also the authority of the man who says, psychologically I know, you don’t.

Because the churches throughout the world, the different religions, have said, give your life to us, we will direct, we’lll shape it, we will tell you what to do. Do this, follow the saviour, follow the church and you will have peace. But, on the contrary churches have produced terrible wars. Religions of every kind have brought about fragmentation of the mind. So the question is not, freedom from a particular authority, but the whole conceptual acceptance of authority.

No, I am not talking of conscience. Our conscience is such a petty little affair.

I don’t say that. No, I haven’t come to that point yet. I am saying that, as we said, we must approach this problem negatively. Which means I must find out what are the blockages.

Obstacles which prevent perception.

Now one of the major blocks, or hindrances, is this total acceptance of authority.

That’s right. So you must be a light to yourself.

No, no sir. No, no. My own authority. What authority have I? My authority is the authority of the society. I am conditioned to accept authority, when I reject the authority of the outer I accept the authority of the inner. And my authority of the inner is the result of the conditioning in which I have been brought up.

Ah, you can’t. Sir, how can a prisoner, except ideologically, or theoretically, accept he is free? He is in prison, and that is the fact from which we must move.

That is one of the major points. And the demand of freedom, not only from authority, but the demand from fear, which makes him accept authority.

So the fear makes man violent, not only territorial violence, but sexual violence and different forms of violence.

So the freedom from authority implies the freedom from fear. And the freedom from fear implies the cessation of every form of violence.

And man has accepted war as the way of life, whether in the office, or at home, or in the playing field, or anywhere war he has accepted as a way of life, which is the very essence of violence.

And aggression and all that is involved. So as long as man accepts violence, lives a way of life which is violent, he perpetuates fear and therefore violence and also accepts authority.

And the churches say, live peacefully, be kind, love your neighbour, which is all sheer nonsense. They don’t mean it. It is merely a verbal assertion that has no meaning at all. It is just an idea because the morality of society which is the morality of the church is immoral.

It’s not going to some place, sir, but understanding this fact that most of us live a life in this ambience, in this cage of authority, fear and violence. We can’t go beyond it, unless one is free from it, not intellectually or theoretically, but actually be free from every form of authority, not the authority of the expert, but the feeling of dependence on authority.

So in trying to learn about fear, there is this division between the observer and the observed. Now is it possible to look at fear without the observer? Please, sir, this is really quite an intricate question, a complex question, one has to go into it very deeply. As long as there is the observer who is going to learn about the fear there is a division.

Therefore in that division is the conflict of trying to get rid of fear, justify fear. So is it possible to look at fear without the observer? So that you are completely in contact with it all the time.

Therefore we are using that word ‘observing’. Being aware of fear without choice, which means the choice implies the observer, choosing whether I don’t like this, or that. Therefore when the observer is absent there is choiceless awareness of fear.

Right. Then what takes place? That’s the whole question. The observer creates the linguistic difference between himself and the thing observed. Language comes in there. Therefore the word prevents being completely in contact with fear.

So the mind is free of the word to look. That is all implied. Sir, look, I want to understand – I mean, the relationship between two people, husband and wife, is the relationship of images.

Obviously. There is no dispute about that. You have your image, and she has her image about you. The relationship is between these two images. Now, the real relationship is, the human relationship is when the images don’t exist. In the same way the relationship between the observer and the observed ceases when the word is not.

There is fear. Now there is fear at the conscious level, which one can understand fairly quickly. But there are the deeper layers of fear, so-called at the hidden parts of the mind. To be aware of that. Now that means is it possible to be aware without analysis? Analysis takes time.

I say it is possible. It is only possible when you are aware during the day what you say, the words you use, the gestures, the way you talk, the way you walk, what your thoughts are, to be completely and totally aware of all that.

It is possible to see the whole of it, during the day. During the day if you are aware of your thoughts, of your feelings, aware of the motives, which demands a mind that is highly sensitive.

Look, sir, if I want to understand something new I must look at it with clear eyes. I can’t bring the past with all the recognition process, with all the memories, and then translate what I see as new. Surely, surely, now just a minute: the man who invented the jet, must have forgotten, or be completely familiar with the propeller, and then there was an absence of knowledge in which he discovered the new.

De novo is not possible, but we have to begin de novo because life demands it, because we have lived in this way, accepting war, hatred, brutality, competition, and anxiety, guilt, all that we have accepted that, we live that way. I am saying to bring about a different quality, a different way of living the past must disappear.

That is what is the whole world is objecting to. The established order says, I can’t let go for the new to be. And the young people throughout the world say, let’s revolt against the old. But they don’t understand the whole complications of it. So they say, what have you given us, except examinations, job, and repetition of the old pattern – war and favourite wars, wars.

The past being the tradition, the past being the pattern of morality, which is the social morality, which is not moral.

Oh, no, no. To break through the past, sir, demands a great deal of intelligence, a great deal of sensitivity to the past. You can’t just break away from it.

A different way in which there are no wars, no hatreds, in which man loves man, without competition, without division, saying you are a Christian, you are a Catholic, you are a Protestant, you are this. That’s all so immature. It has no meaning. It’s an intellectual sophisticated division. And that is not a religious mind at all, that’s not religion. A religious mind is a mind that has no hatred, that lives completely without fear, without anxiety, in which there is not a particle of antagonism. Therefore a mind that loves – that is a different dimension of living altogether. And nobody wants that.

Sir, surely sir, in this is involved the everlasting struggle, conflict, man caught in his own conditioning, and straining, struggling, beating his head to be free. And again we have accepted with the help of religions and all the rest of the group that effort is necessary. That’s part of life. To me that is the highest form of blindness, of limiting man to say, you must everlastingly live in effort.

But to live without effort requires the greatest sensitivity and the highest form of intelligence. You don’t just say, well I won’t struggle, and become like a cow. But one has to understand how conflict arises, the duality in us, the fact of ‘what is’, and ‘what should be’, there is the conflict. If there is no ‘what should be’, which is ideological, which is non real, which is fiction, and see ‘what is’, and face it, live with it without the ‘what should be’, then there is no conflict at all. It’s only when you compare, evaluate with ‘what should be’, and then look with ‘what should be’ at the ‘what is’, then conflict arises.

No ideal at all. Why should we have an ideal? The ideal is the most idiotic form of conceptual thing, why should I have an ideal? The fact is burning there, why should I have an ideal about anything?

Truth is not a mixture of the ideal and the ‘what is’, then you produce some melange of some dirt. There is only ‘what is’. Sir, look, take a very simple example: we human beings are violent. Why should I have an ideal of non-violence? Why can’t I deal with the fact?

Of violence without non-violence. The ideal is an abstraction, is a distraction. The fact is I am violent, man is violent. Let’s tackle that, let’s come to grips with that and see if we can’t live without violence.

Please, there is no dualistic process in this. There is only the fact that I am violent, man is violent, and is it possible to be free of that. Why should I introduce the idealistic nonsense?

Sir, wait, physically there is. You have got a black suit, are a fairer person than me, and so on.

If I felt dualistic I wouldn’t even sit down to discuss with you, then intellectually we play with each other.

No. Sir, when you love somebody with your heart, not with your mind, do you feel separate?

Sir, just a minute, sir. Let’s be a little more unromantic about it. The fact is when there is love between man and woman, in that is involved possession, domination, authority, jealousy, all that is involved in it. Of course there is. And comfort, sexual pleasure, and the remembrance. All that. A bundle of all that.

A bundle of all that. Is love jealousy? Is love pleasure? Is love desire? If it is pleasure it is merely the activity of thought, saying, ‘Well, I slept with that woman, therefore she is mine’ and the remembrance of all that. That’s not love. Thought is not love. Thought breeds fear, thought breeds pain, thought breed pleasure, and pleasure is not love.

What is the positive? What is the positive thing that thought produces, except mechanical things?

Sir, love poem. What? The man feels something and puts it down. The putting down is irrelevant, merely a form of communication. But to feel it is nothing to do with thought. To translate it then it is necessary for thought. But to love…

I don’t think there is a new thought. Thought can never be free because thought is the response of memory, thought is the response of the past.

[When a great poet comes through with the right words to articulate a new perception, nobody has before, not even god, has thought of those particular words.]

That’s a mere matter of a cunning gift of putting words together. But what we are talking about…

[A noble trade.]

Ah, that’s a minor thing. No, sir, that’s a minor thing; the major thing is to see the beauty of life and see the immensity of it, and to love.

(Source: https://terebess.hu/keletkultinfo/krishnamurti/other/1960s/lost_and_found/1968-00-00_conversation_with_huston_smith_1968_claremont,_california.html)

Leave a Reply