Question the Answer, Question the Question – To My Dear Friend Pramod Reddy


Chum, you seem to have spent

Some of your youth

In the company of Nietzsche

How else can I account

For this Dionysian revelry

Of roaming the streets of Bombay

With a camera (maybe a costly one,

Since you are indeed a man of some means)

Slung across your slender shoulder

Maybe with Ravi Kaza in tow

(What is that chap doing now

Whom I would occasionally meet at a quiz,

He being from All Saints High School

Though I doubt if he believed much in saints)

No sooner than your God-given eye

Captures something of delight

You are not satisfied

With the ephemerality of such a glimpse

Or your compassionate and social self

Wants others to view it

Through your eyes

Through your lens

And that is not the only reason

I talk about your Dionysian self

Knowing you now

Since those heady college days

Rumour had it that you smoked weed

And your Mohawk haircut

While at the Gokhale Institute in Pune

Added fuel to those suspicions

Odd that you managed to be so

While reading up Keynes and Friedman

And perhaps Samuelson was your favourite

Who all can drain your spirit

Of all that is worthwhile in life

Chaining your spirit to the Wall Street

And how can you deny your Dionysian self

When you are there in Bombay

In this season of the monsoon

Amidst all this, you can withdraw

At once from the eye

Travelling across the optic nerve

To land in the sweet spot of the brain, your intellect,

And hold forth with me

In purely an Apollonian spirit

Though dyed in your Dionysian self

And talk about compassion

Talk about the corridor of uncertainty

When it comes to seeking answers

To the enigmas of life

And rather intriguingly

You would rather date your questions

Than sleep with any answers

In your own good-humoured but sagely way

And unsettle me for a while

To make me fall into my own being

And question

The veracity of all my answers

(Long live the spirit of Nietzsche and Pramod!)

Leave a comment